| Saturday 24 April 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Margate |
0 (0) |
Scarborough |
2 (1) |
| Saturday 17 April 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Chester |
1 (1) |
Scarborough |
0 (0) |
| Wednesday 14 April 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Telford |
2 (2) |
Scarborough |
1 (1) |
| Monday 12 April 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
2 (0) |
Accrington Stanley |
1 (1) |
| Saturday 10 April 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Burton Albion |
2 (1) |
Scarborough |
0 (0) |
| Tuesday 6 April 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
2 (0) |
Stevenage |
2 (0) |
| Saturday 3 April 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Barnet |
0 (0) |
Scarborough |
0 (0) |
| Saturday 27 March 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
0 (0) |
Dag & Red |
0 (0) |
| Thursday 25 March 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
1 (0) |
Halifax |
0 (0) |
| Tuesday 23 March 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
2 (2) |
Exeter |
3 (2) |
| Saturday 20 March 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Aldershot |
1 (1) |
Scarborough |
2 (0) |
| Tuesday 16 March 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
0 (0) |
Tamworth |
1 (0) |
| Saturday 13 March 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
4 (0) |
Leigh RMI |
1 (0) |
| Saturday 6 March 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Morecambe |
2 (1) |
Scarborough |
1 (0) |
| Saturday 21 February 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Shrewsbury |
4 (0) |
Scarborough |
1 (1) |
| Saturday 7 February 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Forest Green |
4 (2) |
Scarborough |
0 (0) |
| Tuesday 3 February 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
3 (1) |
Hereford |
3 (1) |
| Saturday 24 January 2004 |
| AXA-Sponsored FA Challenge Cup Fourth Round |
| Scarborough |
0 (0) |
Chelsea |
1 (1) |
| Saturday 17 January 2004 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
2 (0) |
Woking |
2 (0) |
| Wednesday 14 January 2004 |
| AXA-Sponsored FA Challenge Cup Third Round |
| Scarborough |
1 (0) |
Southend |
0 (0) |
| Saturday 3 January 2004 |
| AXA-Sponsored FA Challenge Cup Third Round |
| Southend |
1 (1) |
Scarborough |
1 (0) |
| Friday 26 December 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Halifax |
1 (0) |
Scarborough |
0 (0) |
| Saturday 20 December 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
1 (1) |
Northwich |
0 (0) |
| Saturday 13 December 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Farnborough |
1 (1) |
Scarborough |
2 (1) |
| Sunday 7 December 2003 |
| AXA-Sponsored FA Challenge Cup Second Round |
| Port Vale |
0 (0) |
Scarborough |
1 (0) |
| Saturday 29 November 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Gravesend |
1 (1) |
Scarborough |
1 (0) |
| Tuesday 25 November 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
2 (1) |
Barnet |
2 (1) |
| Saturday 22 November 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Dag & Red |
1 (1) |
Scarborough |
0 (0) |
| Saturday 15 November 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
1 (0) |
Aldershot |
0 (0) |
| Tuesday 11 November 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Leigh RMI |
1 (1) |
Scarborough |
4 (1) |
| Saturday 8 November 2003 |
| AXA-Sponsored FA Challenge Cup First Round |
| Scarborough |
1 (0) |
Doncaster |
0 (0) |
| Tuesday 4 November 2003 |
| LDV Vans Trophy Northern Section - Second Round |
| Scarborough |
0 (0) |
Halifax |
1 (0) |
| Saturday 1 November 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
2 (0) |
Chester |
2 (2) |
| Saturday 18 October 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
0 (0) |
Margate |
1 (0) |
| Tuesday 14 October 2003 |
| LDV Vans Trophy Northern Section - First Round |
| Scarborough |
2 (0) |
Port Vale |
1 (1) |
| Saturday 11 October 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Stevenage |
2 (1) |
Scarborough |
2 (0) |
| Tuesday 7 October 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
1 (0) |
Morecambe |
0 (0) |
| Saturday 4 October 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
1 (0) |
Shrewsbury |
1 (1) |
| Saturday 27 September 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Exeter |
0 (0) |
Scarborough |
0 (0) |
| Tuesday 23 September 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Tamworth |
0 (0) |
Scarborough |
0 (0) |
| Saturday 20 September 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
2 (1) |
Forest Green |
2 (1) |
| Saturday 13 September 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Hereford |
2 (1) |
Scarborough |
1 (0) |
| Saturday 6 September 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
2 (0) |
Gravesend |
0 (0) |
| Saturday 30 August 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
1 (1) |
Telford |
1 (0) |
| Monday 25 August 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Accrington Stanley |
1 (0) |
Scarborough |
0 (0) |
| Saturday 23 August 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
1 (1) |
Burton Albion |
2 (2) |
| Saturday 16 August 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Woking |
2 (2) |
Scarborough |
1 (0) |
| Tuesday 12 August 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Northwich |
1 (0) |
Scarborough |
1 (1) |
| Saturday 9 August 2003 |
| The Football Conference |
| Scarborough |
2 (1) |
Farnborough |
1 (0) |
